Alessandro Alessandrini writes in his blog,
It hurts to see many skilled professionals using a “bad” CV to present themselves. It hurts employers as they do not consider into their selection process all the right candidates.
I agree.
What troubles me, though, is that what constitutes a bad (or good) CV is very subjective.
Even if you were able to get any two CV-reviewers to agree on the definition of a good CV, I’d bet money that given the same pile of CV’s to review, they’d end up with different shortlists.
Similarly, I bet that they’d come up with different shortlists on different days. One day, they’re in good moods. But another day . . . . . . might be Monday. Sheesh, will ya look at these CV’s? Give me strength . . . .
Human beings are inherently erratic and unpredictable. And undefinable. You cannot boil one human being’s skills and abilities down to two sheets of A4.
Nor can you have any confidence that the really good candidates will necessarily have the written communication skills to catch my eye 24-7, irrespective of my mood.
(And some would add: HR and recruiter types are notoriously bad at interpreting the CV in light of the manager’s real needs. I say that with all due apologies to the really good HR and recruiters out there – I know you exist.)
No, the really troubling thing for me is that in the 21st Century, we’re still relying on the CV to net us the talent we need.
It was adequate in the 80’s and 90’s. Jobs were scarce, companies were downsizing, and the ratio of vacancies to applicants favoured the employer.
Employers had the luxury of knowing that if they couldn’t see what they wanted quickly on your CV, there were 500 more right behind you. You might be exactly what they needed, but they could afford to lose you in the pile. There would be another good candidate in the pile somewhere.
The CV was a convenient, if inhuman way of cutting down the size of the task and finding the quickest possible solution.
But even in these harder economic times, that luxury has gone. Demographic realities and social media have flattened the playing field somewhat.
However, the same social media tools make it easier for talent-seekers to spread their net wider and more specifically at the same time.
If you’re short of talent, you should be using LinkedIn groups and webinars to build relationships with potential recruits, including ones you don’t even know you want yet.
Recognise that future employees are people. Not a set of skills.
And if you’re out of work, or just plain restless, start blogging about what you’ve done. Start an open-source project. Create an online community around an interest, professional or otherwise. Post Youtube videos featuring your projects. Follow online the companies you’re interested in, an post to their blogs and groups. Don’t delete your CV, because there will always be some old guy somewhere who insists on it. But for heaven’s sake, don’t rely on it.
The companies are people too.
All the tools exist for enabling hands and gloves to meet. What’s missing is effort, and acceptance of how the world has changed.